Design critiques are your best friend. They help you improve and get closer to landing that job role. As a baby designer, you should reach out for critiques and portfolio reviews to improve.
Nothing wrong with that. However, the issue is asking too many people. No two people are the same. Whether it’s recruiters, hiring managers, or designers.
I’ve received critiques that made me go “Yeah, that’s useful” and others where I thought “Absolutely not, but thanks.”
Part of being a designer is knowing when to listen and when to speak.
Find common themes
Separate opinion from fact
Knowing what to keep
I sometimes take part in design reviews. Let people have their say, but that doesn’t mean they need to implement.
It’s like someone asking Ben & Jerry’s to make toothpaste ice cream because they think it’ll be a good flavor. Making an ice cream flavor that 1 out of millions would like wouldn’t be best for business.
Usually, the best feedback to listen to is when there is a common theme.
Enough chit-chat! Here are some tips on how to prioritize opinions on your UX case study and design critique:
1. Consider the source: When evaluating feedback, consider the source of the opinion. Is it coming from a stakeholder who has a vested interest in the project? Or is it coming from a user who has firsthand experience with the product? User feedback should carry more weight than stakeholder feedback, since users are the ones who will be using the product.
2. Look for patterns: When multiple people give similar feedback, it's a good indication that there's an issue that needs to be addressed. Look for patterns in the feedback you receive and prioritize those issues first.
3. Focus on the problem: Instead of getting bogged down in specific solutions, focus on the underlying problem that needs to be solved. This will help you identify which feedback is most valuable in addressing the issue.
4. Consider your goals: When prioritizing feedback, consider your goals for the project. If a particular piece of feedback aligns with your goals, prioritize it over other opinions.
5. Trust your instincts: As a designer, you have expertise in your field. Trust your instincts when evaluating feedback and prioritize opinions that align with your design principles. In conclusion, prioritizing opinions on your UX case study and design critique is essential for improving your designs effectively.
By following the steps above, you’ll prioritize opinions and make the most of your design critique. Go get ‘em, tiger!